Steve Gilliard Comments
From dKosopedia
Steve Gilliard (November 13, 1964 – June 2, 2007) was a freelance journalist and left-wing political blogger who ran the website The News Blog. Before he created that website, he was a commenter and guest poster on Daily Kos.
This page only contains information about Steve Gilliard's blog commenting on Daily Kos; for additional information on his writing see the main Steve Gilliard page.
Contents |
Commenting on Daily Kos
Steve's first comment on Daily Kos was on October 1, 2002, responding to Markos's diary from September 30, NJ Dems have GOP boxed in; the comment thread link is here, and it was signed sgilliard. Subsequent comments were signed steve gilliard until late April 2003, at which point his signature changed to steve_gilliard (though he tried the underscored version on six comments the evening of March 2). He was still using this final form for comment threads on The News Blog in 2007.
List of Comment Links
When Steve started commenting at Daily Kos, the blog was using Movable Type software. Markos was the sole blogger, and comment threads popped up in a separate window. The Movable Type site has subsequently been archived at DailyKos.net, and all links are to that archive.
In the archive, direct links can only be made to individual front-page posts, and to the comment threads of those posts. Only the entire thread can be linked to; there is no way to link to individual posts. So, once you bring up a comment thread in your browser, use the search function to find "gilliard". This will find all of Steve's comments, plus some direct references to those comments or questions to Steve.
In the list of comments below, the date given is the date the particular front-page post was made; it is possible, as in Steve's very first comment, that the actual comment was made the next day. (In the case of his comments to the December 31 diary, they were made the next year.)
The person writing the original front page post is assumed to be Markos; if there was a guest blogger that day—Billmon, Steve Soto, or RonK, Seattle—that blogger will be named. The open threads that Steve Gilliard created are credited to him on this page; if uncredited, open threads are also assumed to be set up by Markos.
2002
September 30:
- NJ Dems have GOP boxed in has one comment . (As "sgilliard".)
October 11:
- Disgusting GOP ad in GA has one comment. (As "steve gilliard", as are all the comments below unless otherwise noted.)
October 24:
October 29:
December 31:
January 2003
January 6:
- The Bush Iraq Vision Emerges by Steve Soto has one comment
January 8:
January 11:
- Why Not Try Soylent Green? by Billmon has one comment
- Strategery by Billmon has two comments
- Delusions of Grandeur by an unsigned Billmon has one comment
- Hubris, Thy Name is Bush by Steve Soto has one comment
January 12:
- Dark Side of the Moon by Billmon has one comment
January 13:
- Return of the Living Dead by Billmon has one comment
January 14:
- Cooking Up a Storm? by Billmon has one comment
January 16:
- Lean Mean Dean Machine? by Billmon has one comment
January 17:
January 20:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Cattle Call 2004: 1/20 has two comments
- True Confessions: war protesters bug me has two comments
January 21:
- US heading into Iraq alone has three comments
- Kennedy sets the bar has one comment
- US has almost no Security Council support has one comment
January 22:
- Hart runs strong on National Security (but can we forget Donna?) has one comment
- November to January -- night and day has one comment
- Cattle Call at NARAL has five comments
- Boxgate revealed has one comment
January 23:
- Diplomacy, Bush style has one comment
- Bush cries "wolf" has two comments
- Spitzer to file amicus supporting UMichigan has one comment
January 27:
- War opposition still increasing has five comments
- Cattle Call 2004: 1/27 has one comment
- GOP is still party of racists has two comments
January 28:
- Still no war justification has one comment
- Bush's SOTU has one comment
- Bush's SOTU, Part II has one comment
- Final thoughts and Open Thread has two comments
January 29:
- Open thread has one comment
- Markets fall, bigger deficits has one comment
- Gary Locke's response has one comment
January 30:
- Rush boycott starting to show results has one comment
- No conclusive evidence has two comments
- Nelson Mandela and Bishop rip into Bush has one comment
January 31:
- Open Thread has one comment
- GOP rates our candidates has one comment
- Cheney supports Confederate Flag! has two comments
February 2003
February 1:
February 2:
- Did Bush get a SOTU bump? has two comments
- FBI, CIA both reject Iraq-Al Qaeda link has three comments
February 3:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Bush's budget-busting budget has one comment
- Ashcroft bags his "marijuana guru" has two comments
February 4:
- 'Borrow and Spend' Republicans has two comments
- Richard Perle: France no longer an ally has one comment
- Learning to organize has one comment
February 5:
- Bush never went to Houston Space Center has one comment
- Powell's "Adlai moment" has four comments
- North Korea restarts nuclear reactor has two comments
February 6:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Cheney's endorsement of "great ideas" has one comment
- News from the economic front has one comment
February 7:
- Open Thread (posted by Steve Soto) has one comment
- Remember That "Dead or Alive" Guy? What Was His Name?... by Steve Soto has two comments
- Are You Ready for Patriot Act II? by Steve Soto has one comment
- Fighting Back by Steve Soto has one comment
February 8:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Britain’s Iraq Dossier Came From Magazines by Steve Soto has one comment
- How Do You Like Your New Friends Now, James Hoffa Jr.? by Steve Soto has two comments
February 9:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Iraq Update-And How Useless is Wolf Blitzer? by Steve Soto has one comment
- Bush Has Lost the Security Council by Steve Soto has one comment
- Bush Will Face Opposition From Both Russia and the Vatican by Steve Soto has one comment
February 10:
- Open Thread has one comment
- O'Reilly slurs Latinos has three comments
- Cattle Call 2004: comment period has one comment
February 11:
- Cattle Call 2004: 2/11 has four comments
- OBL hates Saddam; Powell loses cred has two comments
- Estrada filibuster is on has two comments
February 12:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Fools in the desert has one comment
- In Iowa, voters oppose war has one comment
- One war scenario has six comments
- Follow up on "One war scenario" has three comments, and the post text front-pages an earlier comment by Steve
February 13:
- ANSWER bans rabbi from speaking at SF rally has three comments
- Estrada filibuster officially on has two comments
- Bush budget explicit cause of deficits has two comments
- 38 percent approve of Bush's handling of economy has three comments
February 14:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Bush may have 5x more money than Dems has one comment
- Hans Blix: Inspections working has two comments
- Everyone needs to chill has two comments
- Our nation's real enemy still exists has two comments
February 15:
- Open Thread has two comments
- Sending a grassroots message to DNC HQ has seven comments
- Millions say "no" to war has one comment
- No shots fired yet, and everything is already FUBAR has one comment
February 16:
- Open Thread has four comments
- Ashcroft tried to prevent NYC protests has one comment
- Kucinich to enter the race has one comment
- Protests largest in countries backing US has one comment
- Greenspan's future in doubt has one comment
February 17:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Cremation plans dropped has one comment
- Direct action could shut down UK has one comment
- Blair, Howard down in polls has three comments
February 18:
- Open Thread has one comment
- US war plans hit snag with Turkey has two comments
- Fundraising for the DNC has one comment
- Open Thread II has two comments
- Iran-backed rebels enter Iraq has one comment
- White House presses Estrada nomination has one comment
February 19:
- Tom Friedman Does Another 180 on Bush by Steve Soto has two comments
- Cattle Call: 2/19 has one comment
- Start the Countdown to Bombing by Steve Soto has six comments
- Has a Subtle Powell Scapegoating Begun? by Steve Soto has one comment
February 20:
- Thursday Morning Iraq Update by Steve Soto has four comments
- And Now Back to Politics for a Moment by Steve Soto has one comment
February 21:
- Open Thread has two comments
- Iraq and Ken Pollack by Steve Soto has seven comments
- Turkey agrees to US forces (almost) has one comment
- The price of war has two comments
- Dean brings down the house has six comments
February 22:
- Simon to challenge Boxer has one comment
- Could Gephardt win? has two comments
- Governors to meet with Bush has three comments
February 23:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Pollack's arguments a house of cards has four comments
- Americans believe war will increase terror has five comments
- Bush admin still crying about Estrada has three comments
February 24:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Cattle Call 2004: comment Period 2/24 has two comments
- Bush running scared at governor's meeting has five comments
- North Korea fires missile has one comment
- Help elect Iraq's civil admininstrator has two comments
February 25:
- Cattle Call: 2/25 has one comment
- 'Coalition of the unwilling'; 2nd resolution has five comments
- Our emergency powers are OK, Egypt's are not has one comment
February 26:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Ari laughed off the stage has one comment
- The latest in the Estrada saga has one comment
- Tom DeLay's appeasement has one comment
February 27:
- Open Thread has four comments
- Turkey parliament delays war vote again has two comments
- The costs of war, according to Bush has two comments
- Hoffa lashes out at Bush has one comment
- Bush: hurry up and drop bombs! has one comment
- Rice may run for CA governor has one comment
- Novak: GOP loss on Estrada imminent has three comments
February 28:
- Open Thread has four comments
- Bush turns guns on House, Senate has two comments
- US to sue California over gun database has one comment
- Return of the living dead by Billmon has two comments
- Out of Africa by Billmon has three comments
- Raising Hamas by Billmon has one comment
March 2003
March 1:
- Takes One to Know One by Billmon has four comments
- South of the Border by Billmon has two comments
- Pressed Turkey by Billmon has four comments
- The Clinton Factor by Billmon has one comment
- The Sound of Silence by Billmon has one comment
- Do These Men Work for the Same Government? by Billmon has three comments
- The Big Fish by Billmon has three comments
Note: for the six comments on March 2 made starting at 5:15pm, Steve's signature changed from "steve gilliard" to "steve_gilliard". It reverted the next day, but would change back permanently in late April.
March 2:
- Snake Eyes by Billmon has six comments (first three as "steve gilliard"; last three as "steve_gilliard")
- Open Thread has one comment ("steve gilliard")
- Please Speak Clearly into the Lamp by Billmon has two comments (first as "steve gilliard"; second as "steve_gilliard")
- No Means Yes by Billmon has one comment ("steve_gilliard")
- Baghdad Rules by Billmon has one comment ("steve_gilliard")
March 3:
- Networks and WH in pissing match has one comment
- US refuses to surrender Turkey plan has three comments
- Let's help Bush with some campaign slogans has three comments
March 4:
- Open Thread has three comments
- Cattle Call 2004: 3/4 has two comments
- Barbour picks up primary challenger has two comments
- The logistics of a one-front war has eight comments
March 5:
- Open Thread has two comments
- Second UN resolution dead in water has two comments
March 6:
- Open Thread has three comments
- Blair shifts position has two comments
- Soldier tax relief bill a boon for special interests has two comments
- Estrada filibuster holds has one comment
- Winner of the Bush admin hypocrisy challenge has two comments
- US and Pakistan on Bin Laden's trail. Maybe. has one comment
- Bush -- gasp! -- stages press conference has eight comments
March 7:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Bush stirs up mob hate against Mexicans has two comments
- Reviews are in: Bush sucked has one comment
- Pelosi dresses down Dems over Iraq has three comments
- Bush's deficits has two comments
March 8:
- Scenes from the Next War by Billmon has one comment
- Good Old Boys by Billmon has one comment
March 9:
- Open Thread has five comments
March 10:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Blair's party may split over Iraq has one comment
- Pakistan will abstain has two comments
- Poppy Bush to Jr: slow down has one comment
- New resolution delayed has one comment
March 11:
- Open Thread has three comments
- Partial-birth abortion bill set to pass has one comment
- Is Bush II 'multilateral'? has four comments
March 12:
- Iraqi "drone" made of duct tape has two comments
- Kurtz serves up bad news galore for Bush has two comments
March 13:
- Turkey driving a hard bargain has one comment
- Blair: resolution "less likely" has one comment
- Senate passes abortion bill has one comment
- White House controls press has three comments
March 14:
- Candidates stump in Spanish has two comments
- Coalition of the Three to stage summit has one short comment
- In the "rest of day" Open Thread, Steve had two comments
March 15:
- "Open Thread for Iraq comments only" has nine comments.
March 16:
- An Iraq Open Thread started the day, and Steve wrote three comments
- Blair steels himself for 2-front war has eight comments
March 17:
- In Perhaps they've heard the expression in Vegas, he has two sentences on Tony Blair and the war
- On war and Democrats has two comments
- US/UK: 1441 is good enough has four comments
- The Open Thread on Bush's speech has three comments
- Bush's declaration of war has six comments
March 18:
- With the invasion of Iraq imminent, the morning Iraq open thread had three comments from Steve (it looks like four, but the first two are a double-post of the same text)
- Blair asks for support in parliament has three comments
- $90 billion for war nets one comment
- Chickenhawks pile on Daschle also gets one
- No US troops in Turkey, but overflights nets one as well
March 19:
- Turkey deals a blow to US gets four comments
- War rumors run rampant nets three comments
- The sole comment in Now they talk about costs! More WH b.s. is stark:
The war has started
Posted by steve gilliard at March 19, 2003 06:48 PM
- Steve then had six comments in the War Open Thread to end the day
March 20:
- If we kill Saddam, what then? has four comments
- Iraqis start blowing oil wells gets six comments
- What happened to "Shock and Awe"? receives four comments
- Forbes: dKos top "warblog" gets a one-line comment
- Is the US negotiating with Republican Guard? gets two comments
March 21:
- As the invasion continues, the Open Thread has two comments
- Pockets of resistance unfolding garners a single comment
- He wrote two comments in a single-picture diary entitled "Bush's Legacy"
- Is Saddam dead? Who cares? includes one comment
March 22:
- The Open Thread has three comments
- Guerilla attacks; 4th ID gets one comment
- Sigh... about the death of a Marine gets one comment
- Pushing forth, avoiding cities has three comments
- Some fraying on the edges has two comments
March 23:
- The next Open Thread receives two comments
- Geneva convention; logistics has two comments
- Holy shit, people die in war? has one comment
- Urban combat in Basra has one comment
- Moore blasts Bush has one comment
- The face of war has one comment
- Underestimating Iraqi will to fight has two comments
- Let's not forget Afghanistan has one short comment
March 24:
- Open Thread receives one comment
- Not a quagmire. Yet. has two comments
- Apaches downed, rethinking strategy has two comments
- Bush gets war bounce has one comment
- Republican Guard; Nasiriyah; Civilian casualties has one short comment
March 25:
- Why weren't the bridges blown? receives one comment
- Jose Angel Garibay has two comments
- Congress cuts Bush's tax cut in half has one short comment
- Big US victory, Iraqi overconfidence? has two comments
March 26:
- Open Thread receives two comments
- Stunning victories in Bush's War on the World has one comment
- Iraqi tactics are a boon to war effort has seven comments
- More From Officer X by Billmon has four comments from Steve
- Thomas J. Slocum, 22 has two comments
March 27:
- Open Thread receives two comments
- Status report has three comments
- All's (relatively) quiet on the Iraqi front has three comments
- Jessica Lynch has one comment
- US storms out at UN has one short comment
- Perle resigns also has one short comment
March 28:
- Comments were down as the day started due to server and database problems.
March 29:
- Victory no longer inevitable has four comments
- War status update 3/29 has four comments
- The silliness of counting Iraqi casualties has three comments
- Reality Check has one comment
March 30:
- Open Thread receives one comment
- Brass turns on Rumsfeld has four comments
- Clark in 2004? I'm leaning that way has one comment
- Unknown girl, unknown age, wounded has two comments
March 31:
- Open Thread receives four comments
- Just like Saddam (if not worse), but our ally has two comments
- Trigger happy yanks has two comments
- Anti-war GOP emboldened has one comment
- Who cares if Saddam is dead? has one comment
- "A Lack of Character" by Billmon has four comments from Steve
April 2003
April 1:
- Open Thread receives two comments
- Finding a way out has three comments
- Eugene Williams, 25, Sgt has three comments
- Jessica Lynch rescued has two comments
April 2:
- Open Thread receives seven comments
- Bush is depressed has three comments
Important note: as of April 3, Steve became a guest poster on the front page. All comments that Steve wrote on his own posts can be found on the Steve Gilliard Posts page, listed with the original post.
April 3:
- Fog of War? Or Fog of Lies? by Billmon has one comment
- The Holistic Shooting Match by Billmon has one comment
April 4:
- Steve's Open Thread has five comments by him
- Scenes From the Burma Railway by Billmon has two comments
- Defining Victory Down by Billmon has one comment
April 5:
- Steve's Open Thread also has two comments by him
- What the War is NOT About by Billmon has one comment
- Our Man in Baghdad by Billmon has one comment
April 6:
- The Open Thread is unsigned, but kos wasn't yet back, and Billmon has no comments in it, while Steve has two comments. Which of them would say "But PLEASE don't feed the trolls . . ."?
- Science Experiment by Billmon has one comment
April 7
- The Open Thread has two comments
April 8:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Norm Coleman: another "classy" Republican has one comment
- Cattle Call 2004: 4/8 -- the money edition has one comment
April 10:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Much work left to be done has two comments
- Baseball Hall of Fame cancels Sarandon appearance has two comments
- What is it with racist Republicans? garners one comment
April 12:
- Steve's Open Thread has one comment by him
- Bust a Deal, Face the Wheel by RonK, Seattle, has one short comment
April 13:
- The Open Thread by Steve also has two comments by him
- Juxtapositions, and Perspectives by RonK, Seattle, has two comments
April 14:
- Steve's Open Thread has two comments by him
April 15:
April 16:
- Open Thread has two comments
- First Abbas in Bahgdad, next Bosch in Miami has one comment
- So will Gary Hart run? has two comments
- Tim Robbins at the National Press Club has one comment
April 17:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Syria countermoves, scores against US has one comment
- Still no WMDs in Iraq has one comment
April 18:
- Open Thread has one comment
- Massive protests against US has five comments
After April 18, 2003
Comments posted by Steve after April 18 and until the Movable Type (archived) Daily Kos site was shut down on October 15, 2003, will be added as their links are retrieved from the archive. As this is a labor-intensive process, the task will take weeks or months to complete.
Links to Daily Kos comments on current site
Here is a link that will let you can find the 1200 comments Steve wrote on the current Daily Kos site (Scoop-based; opened October 13, 2003). He wrote under two accounts: stevegilliard (userid 1565) accounts for the bulk of them (1150), from October 16, 2003—the day after the Movable Type site closed and was archived—to January 19, 2007, but in 2004, he created steve gilliard (userid 9795) and used it to write 50 comments in a two-month period between April 14 and June 13, 2004, during which the first account wasn't used. Fortunately, a single search can get links to all 1200 comments, though it will take approximately half a minute to complete and the links will only display 50 at a time:
- Steve Gilliard's comments (1200)
If you wish, you can search under each account separately:
- stevegilliard (1150 comments)
- steve gilliard (50 comments)
Original Source
This page is based on the Daily Kos diaries Top Comments: Steve Gilliard on Daily Kos, part 1 published on March 19, 2008; and Steve Gilliard on Daily Kos, part 6 published on June 3, 2008; with additional material from Top Comments: Steve Gilliard on Daily Kos, part 2, published on March 21, 2008. All diaries were written by sardonyx.